We do not support this application.
This former office block has already achieved planning permission for part change of use and part redevelopment to mainstream residential use. In our view this approved redevelopment should go ahead.
In November 2023, Councillors during a Full Council meeting in Edinburgh overwhelmingly voted to recognise and seek to address the scale of Edinburgh’s housing crisis by officially declaring a Housing Emergency.
In view of this declaration we believe that it would be inconsistent with this declaration for the Council to approve this new application.
We object to this application which, in our view, represents the commercialisation of an important area of public space which provides heritage interest, amenity and access in the heart of the Old Town. We cannot support this proposed change of use.
The City of Edinburgh Museums Service describes Makars’ Court as ‘an evolving national monument’ with ‘famous words of great Scottish authors inscribed in the flagstones’. This application does not support the court’s continuing development as al literary heritage asset.
We understand that Makars’ Court is a Common Good asset. Under Part 8 of the Community Empowerment (Scotland) Act 2015, Local Authorities as required to carry out a consultation exercise when seeking to change the use, or sell, any properties forming part of the Common Good. This application includes an area of commercial space and represents a change of use, in our view, and, as such, representation should have been sought on this proposal through an appropriate consultation. exercise in the terms of the Community Empowerment (Scotland) Act 2015 .
Two ‘little’ ice ages and an anomaly: climate, environment and cultural change in medieval and early modern Scotland
The Cockburn Association supports this application.
We acknowledge that this is a constrained site with development challenges. Bearing this in mind, PBSA redevelopment is an acceptable use of the site which will secure much of the remaining external heritage interest.
This former mill has been extensively modified over its history and most of its heritage features have been lost. However, we would ask that an effort be made to salvage any remaining art deco features of interest either for reuse on site or for incorporation into other projects elsewhere.
We are generally supportive of PBSA developments which feature cluster flats in their design since these offer a better student living environment and are more likely to offer future opportunities for conversion to mainstream housing should market demand for student housing diminish.
We are aware of local concerns regarding this and nearby student accommodation developments in the context of the city’s ongoing housing emergency. It is now essential that the City of Edinburgh Council commissions an independent data-driven student needs assessment for Edinburgh to inform the Council’s current and future planning position on student housing needs in the City.
It is clear that Edinburgh has a significant and varied housing need with many permanent and transitory residents facing real challenges in their search for suitable and affordable accommodation. A growing student population runs the risk of exasperating an already difficult balance of housing needs and supply.
A new Edinburgh-wide student needs assessment is now urgently required to provide a robust evidence base from which consideration can be given to how to manage student accommodation now and in the future, including reviewing the threshold for the numbers of university students living outside of managed accommodation; and policies for the delivery of purpose-built student accommodation (PBSA).
A deep dive into the history of the glass industry in Edinburgh and the Lothians
Celebrate the life and works of Robert Fergusson