The histories, legacies, and repatriation of Edinburgh’s African skull collections
Surprising and touching experiences, specially curated for Edinburgh’s 900th year.
Malik Al Nasir explores Black and British history and his new book
A group wildlife recording excursion.
Explore four centuries of objects from the National Museum and NTS properties.
A free monthly tour of the exhibition in the University of Edinburgh’s Main Library.
Objection: heritage, visual impact, structural concerns, scrutiny.
Objection: heritage, visual impact, structural concerns, scrutiny.
The Cockburn Association objects to the planning applications 25/03537/FUL and 25/03538/LBC. Our concerns centre on the potential impact upon the character of the New Town Conservation Area, the integrity of the listed building, and the wider Edinburgh World Heritage Site.
Visual and Heritage Impact
The applications are not supported by adequate visual impact assessments, particularly verified views from key public vantage points such as Calton Hill and surrounding streetscapes. Views from Castle and glimpses from the Old Town also very important. Without these, it is not possible to assess the full implications of the proposals on the New Town Conservation Area or the setting of the listed building. We consider that the development risks eroding the established character and appearance of this highly sensitive historic environment. We therefore request that detailed visualisations are provided and assessed in line with relevant heritage policies.
Listed Building Integrity
We are concerned about the potential impact of additional roof loading and other alterations on the structural stability of the listed building. It is vital that any proposal demonstrates that the historic fabric of the building will not be compromised. We urge the planning authority to subject any structural assessments to rigorous scrutiny before determination.
Determination by Committee
Given the prominence of the site and its heritage sensitivity, we support the request made by Marks and Spencer that the application be determined by the Development Management Sub-Committee rather than under delegated powers. This will ensure appropriate public scrutiny and a full consideration of the heritage impacts.
For these reasons, we ask that the applications be refused in their current form.
Co-produced by EDAS and Historic Environment Scotland
