Willowbrae

Cockburn Response

The Cockburn Association welcomes the redevelopment of this long-standing brownfield site and considers that the proposal represents a significant improvement upon the existing condition of this prominent gateway location. The scheme demonstrates a coherent urban design strategy, responding positively to the street geometry and reinforcing the urban frontage along Willowbrae Road and Northfield Road. The use of durable materials, the integration of landscaping and sustainable drainage, and the provision of active travel infrastructure are all positive aspects of the proposal.

The Association particularly welcomes the applicant’s continued refinement of the scheme through the planning process and recognises that the design has evolved from earlier approved proposals.

However, the Association considers there remains scope for further design refinement. Given the strategic importance of this eastern gateway into Edinburgh, the architecture could provide a stronger civic presence through greater articulation of the principal corner and richer façade modelling. Similarly, opportunities exist to enhance the public realm through a more generous landscape setting, reduced visual dominance of surface parking where practicable, and measures to ensure the ground-floor commercial unit provides an active and enduring contribution to street life.

Subject to these observations, the Cockburn Association considers that the proposal makes a generally positive contribution to the townscape and raises no objection in principle to the application. It encourages the planning authority and applicant to continue refining the architectural detailing and public realm to ensure that the completed development fully realises the potential of this important gateway site.