Western Harbour

Cockburn Response

The Cockburn Association has submitted an objection to planning application 25/01762/FUL for 154 new apartments at Western Harbour. While we recognise the urgent need for new homes in Edinburgh and welcome residential development in principle, this proposal fails to demonstrate the design ambition or contextual sensitivity expected at such a prominent waterfront location.

The architectural design and overall site layout are disappointing, with little evident effort to engage meaningfully with the site’s maritime character. The buildings appear generic in form and do not respond to the opportunity presented by the waterfront setting.

Of particular concern is the treatment of the existing water features. Despite a long-running community campaign to retain and protect the established ponds and surrounding habitat, now home to a wide range of wildlife, this application offers little clarity on how the surviving feature will be sensitively integrated into the wider development. The absence of a clear landscape or ecological framework is a missed opportunity and weakens the wider masterplan.

We urge the applicant and planners to reconsider the quality, sustainability, and contextual response of the proposals—ensuring that any new development adds lasting value to Edinburgh’s waterfront and reflects community expectations.