Refusal of Student Accommodation at Dalton Scrapyard: Detailed Analysis

POSTED ON February 19, 2025 BY James Garry

The proposed flat block failed to meet parts of Edinburgh’s Development Plan.

The proposed flat block failed to meet parts of Edinburgh’s Development Plan.

Support the Cockburn

Donate
Join Us

Seafield Regeneration: Have Your Say!

POSTED ON  BY James Garry

Residents are invited to share their views on the regeneration of Seafield

Residents are invited to share their views on the regeneration of Seafield

Support the Cockburn

Donate
Join Us

The Gaelic Place-Names of Edinburgh

Sat, 22 Mar 2025

Learn how Gaelic has influenced the names of Edinburgh’s streets, landscape, and buildings.

Book Here

West Park Place PBSA

Posted on: February 13, 2025

The existing buildings are not listed but have been identified as locally significant

The existing buildings are not listed but have been identified as locally significant

Cockburn Response

This planning application involves the demolition of the existing buildings at 2 – 3 West Park Place, Edinburgh. The site will be redeveloped to construct purpose-built student accommodation, which will include ancillary amenities, cycle parking, landscaping, and other associated works. The existing buildings are not listed but have been flagged as locally significant by appropriate City of Edinburgh Council officers. There has been local interest and local objections.

The Cockburn Association objects to this application.  We  are not convinced that the case for the complete demolition of all the existing buildings is justified.

The height, mass, and bulk of the proposals seem excessive for such a constrained site in a heavily residential area, and there are no new accessible greenspaces or additional amenity benefits for the area’s existing community.

The application does not discuss the cumulative impact of adding additional student accommodation to an area which already has built and consented PBSA accommodation.

Additionally, while we acknowledge that most of the accommodation proposed is in cluster configurations, we would have liked to have seen a fuller discussion of how this development could be effectively and affordably reconfigured as mainstream housing if the demand for PBSA should fall in the future.

Treasures of The Library

Wednesday, March 26 ·

Join The Royal College of Surgeons of Edinburgh Library and Archive to view some of their rarest collections

Book Here

Celebrating Edinburgh’s Voices – An Edinburgh 900 Exhibition

Friday, March 21 - 22

Exciting exhibition representing diverse voices from a community hub in Edinburgh’s Old Town,

Book Here

Our Milling Heritage

Mon, 24 Feb 2025

‘Possibly the most useful river in the whole of Scotland’

Book Here

Community Stories – Community Archives: Edinburgh

Thursday, February 27

An in-person workshop focused on caring for and sharing community archives

Book Here

World Heritage & Climate Action webinar – # 3

Tuesday 11th March 2025

World Heritage Site – Old and New Towns of Edinburgh

Book Here

Rockville: James Gowans’ ‘Romantic Rationalist’ Masterpiece

Mon, 10 Mar 2025

Andy Arthur looks at the history of this remarkable building and its builder, James Gowans.

Book Here