Place Hotel
Posted on: November 20, 2026
We do not support the application in its present form
Address: The Place Hotel 34 – 38 York Place New Town Edinburgh EH1 3HU
Proposal: Reconfigure existing accommodation, enhance accessibility, extension to rear, demolition of detached Victorian stone villa at rear.
Reference: 26/04282/LBC
Closing date for comments: Fri 27 Nov 2026
Determination date: Sun 27 Dec 2026
Result: Pending

Cockburn Response
The Cockburn Association welcomes the additional setback from York Lane and the proposed improvements to step-free access. Both are worthwhile changes to the scheme we commented on under 26/01440/LBC. We remain concerned about the proposed demolition and the extent of internal change across the three Category A listed townhouses.
First, we ask the Council to clarify the designation status and significance of the detached Victorian villa and to identify separately the elements of the existing east wing proposed for removal. The case for demolition should show what repair, adaptation and partial retention could achieve, and why a scheme retaining more of the existing fabric has been discounted.
Second, we ask for a house-by-house schedule of the internal works, showing the age and significance of the fabric affected and how the principal rooms, stairs and circulation of each house would remain legible. Please distinguish the works needed to deliver the access improvements from those associated with the increase in bedroom numbers. A clear plan of the step-free routes and room provision would help explain the benefit of the proposed changes.
Finally, the York Lane setback is a welcome revision. We ask that the extension be tested in dimensioned sections and closely framed views from York Lane and Dublin Street Lane South. These should show how its height, façade and roofline, including terrace screening and any plant, relate to the rear of the listed terrace and the smaller scale of the lanes.
The revised scheme makes progress on access and the treatment of the lane. On the evidence available to us, the case for demolition and the extent of the internal alterations remain unresolved. We do not support the application in its present form.
