Local Place Plans: giving Edinburgh’s communities a say that counts

POSTED ON November 20, 2026

Local Place Plans offer a way to begin earlier

By the time residents are asked to comment on a planning application, the applicant may already have invested considerable time and money in a preferred use, scale and layout. Those choices remain open to scrutiny, but communities can find themselves responding to assumptions they had little opportunity to shape.

Local Place Plans offer a way to begin earlier. They allow a community to set out what it values about its neighbourhood, where it would welcome change and what that change should achieve. Their value depends on what happens next. The work has to influence later decisions, and communities have to be able to see that it has. Much of that rests with the Council.

What is a Local Place Plan?

Local Place Plans were introduced by the Planning (Scotland) Act 2019. They are community-led proposals for the development and use of land, and they can identify buildings and land of particular local significance and set out priorities for their future.

In Edinburgh, a plan might identify opportunities for affordable homes, seek to retain workshops or cultural premises, propose better walking routes, or protect valued green space. The strongest plans look at how a neighbourhood works as a whole, including the shops, services and connections that daily life depends on, rather than treating each site in isolation.

Specificity helps. A community that has identified a missing pedestrian link between housing and its local centre can map the route across a likely redevelopment site and explain how it would improve access to shops and the bus stop. A future developer then has a clear, located priority to respond to, rather than a general aspiration.

Seventeen plans are now on the Council’s register, from the Old Town, Leith and Balerno to Wester Hailes and Midmar Paddock, ranging from whole neighbourhoods to a single, tightly defined place.

Preparing a plan

A Local Place Plan must be prepared and submitted by an eligible community body: a community council, or an organisation that meets the statutory definition of a community-controlled body. Others can contribute, but the body responsible must qualify.

The prescribed format is relatively flexible, which leaves room for a plan that is readable and proportionate. It must identify the community body, include a map of the area it covers and set out its proposals for the use and development of land, with locations mapped where required. In preparing it, the body must have regard to the National Planning Framework, the local development plan and any relevant Locality Plan. The supporting information must explain how it has done so. Where the plan proposes changes to the local development plan, it must give reasons. It must also describe the level and nature of community support, and the basis for that assessment.

Before submission, the plan and an information notice must be sent to the relevant ward councillors and to the community councils covering or adjoining the area, allowing at least 28 days for representations.

The overlap in terminology can mislead. The Edinburgh Community Plan is the Edinburgh Partnership’s Local Outcome Improvement Plan, prepared under the Community Empowerment (Scotland) Act 2015. Its associated Locality Plans focus on improving outcomes and reducing inequalities in particular areas. These documents have a different purpose from Local Place Plans, but the systems are connected: the Council must take the Community Plan into account when preparing its local development plan, while communities preparing Local Place Plans must have regard to any applicable Locality Plan.

That connection is becoming more concrete. The Partnership’s June 2026 refresh of the Community Plan commits it to co-designing Locality Plans in five Neighbourhood Prevention Partnership areas: Wester Hailes, Restalrig, Liberton, Craigmillar and Pilton.

Meeting these requirements is necessary, but it does not make a plan credible. Credibility comes from the engagement behind it. Walking the area with residents, holding meetings people can actually get to, and giving room to argue through competing priorities all count for more than a well-drawn map.

Who takes part matters as much as how. Evening meetings suit some people and exclude others; tenants, younger residents, disabled people, carers and shift workers are often poorly served by them. A good plan is candid about whose views it gathered, where disagreement remains and which groups it found hard to reach. A plan that claims a single community view will be easier to set aside.

What weight do they carry?

Registration is often misunderstood. When the Council registers a plan, it is confirming that the plan meets the legal requirements. It is not endorsing the proposals on their planning merits, nor confirming that they can be delivered.

Once registered, a plan must be taken into account when the Council prepares or amends its local development plan. This is a duty to consider the plan, not to adopt its proposals.

The immediate opportunity is City Plan 2040. The Council has confirmed that its Evidence Report passed the Scottish Government’s Gate Check on 1 October 2026, so work on the Proposed Plan can now proceed. Registered Local Place Plans are an established route by which community proposals can inform it.

We urge the Council to publish a clear account of how each registered plan has shaped City Plan 2040: which proposals have been carried forward, which have been modified and which have not been accepted, with reasons tied to the evidence and the relevant planning considerations. A general statement that community plans have been “taken into account” would not show residents how their work influenced the outcome.

Local Place Plans and Place Briefs

A Local Place Plan is prepared by a community body and sets out its proposals for how land and buildings should be used or developed. A Place Brief is prepared by the Council for a particular site or area, informed by engagement and site assessment. It sets out what the Council expects a development proposal to address, such as access, landscape and the layout of buildings.

Astley Ainslie shows how the two can work together. The Council describes its draft Place Brief for the site as bringing together the community vision in the Astley Ainslie Community Trust’s Local Place Plan, an assessment of the site, and NHS aspirations. Consultation closed on 11 November 2026. The Council states that, once finalised and approved by committee, the brief will become planning guidance and a material consideration in determining applications.

A Local Place Plan can help shape a Place Brief, as at Astley Ainslie. Once approved as planning guidance, the brief gives landowners and developers a basis for shaping proposals before they apply for permission. A complex site may also need a masterplan to show how buildings, landscape, access, infrastructure and phasing fit together.

When an application arrives

The starting point for any decision remains the development plan, which in Edinburgh comprises National Planning Framework 4 and City Plan 2030, adopted on 7 November 2024. Applications must be determined in accordance with the development plan unless material considerations indicate otherwise.

Relevant proposals in a Local Place Plan can be material considerations in deciding an application. An approved Place Brief can also be a material consideration where its guidance applies to the site and the proposal. Both sit outside the statutory development plan. The decision-maker must take material considerations into account and decide how much weight to give them in each case. For example, a mapped walking route in a Local Place Plan and access principles in an approved Place Brief could both bear on whether a proposed layout would provide a usable link through the site.

For a community responding to an application, the task is practical. Identify the relevant proposals in the Local Place Plan, explain how the application supports or conflicts with them, and connect those points to development plan policies and evidence of local impact. Having a plan strengthens a response. It does not remove the need to make one.

Making participation worthwhile

Residents see what individual decisions can miss, which is how separate developments add up. The gradual loss of affordable workspace, mounting pressure on community facilities, and the slow erosion of the routes and green spaces that make a neighbourhood liveable are rarely obvious from a single application. They are plain to the people who live with them. Local Place Plans are one of the few means of putting that knowledge before decision-makers while the choices are still open.

There is also a question of fairness. Preparing a plan takes time, confidence and often specialist help, and these are not evenly distributed across the city. Communities with fewer resources need practical support from the Council: officer time, help with mapping and data, and guidance on what a proportionate plan looks like. Nor should the absence of a Local Place Plan be read as an absence of concern or ambition.

A common, optional template and a short set of practical guidance notes would give communities a starting point for mapping proposals, recording local support and setting out priorities. A shared format would help communities learn from one another and make it easier for the Council, developers and other stakeholders to compare plans and see where priorities overlap. It could build on the guides, examples and tools already available. Our Place and Scottish Community Development Centre.

The two systems should work together. Wester Hailes already has a registered Local Place Plan and is now a Neighbourhood Prevention Partnership area. The Partnership’s Place Partnership is well placed to make sure that Locality Plans in these neighbourhoods draw on existing Local Place Plans, and to support communities wishing to prepare Local Place Plans, building on existing plans and community organisations.

Others have their part to play. Developers should read relevant community plans at the outset, not once a scheme is fixed. The Council should explain how those plans have influenced its policies, briefs and decisions. Communities should have the opportunity to revisit their priorities as circumstances change.

Local Place Plans offer Edinburgh a way to connect citywide responsibilities with the experience of particular streets and neighbourhoods. Their success should be measured by whether residents can trace their proposals through to policy and decisions. Where the Council takes a different course, residents are owed a reasoned explanation.

Sources and Information

Image: Jeffrey Street from East Market Street, Edinburgh. Photograph by Stephencdickson, Wikimedia Commons (CC0).

Support the Cockburn

Donate
Join Us