Former Royal High School proposals win Cockburn support

Cockburn Response

The Association has examined the planning and listed building consent applications by the Royal High School Preservation Trust for the repurposing and refurbishment of the former Royal High School.  We have recollected our substantial history of engagement with this iconic structure, acknowledged as the one of the finest Greek Revival building in the world, more than justifying its Category A-listing.  We have also benefited from a detailed site visit with the applicant and architects, when we were able to assess the internal changes as well as external.

The Association supports the proposals to form new premises for the National Centre for Music including music rehearsal and performance spaces, licensed cafe /restaurant and bar facilities, offices, internal and external alterations, landscaping, public realm including provision of external multi-use space for temporary events/festival uses.

We agree with the assessment of Historic Environment Scotland that the proposals would return the main building closer to its original solitary setting on the site.  The loss of most of the later buildings will enable the Hamilton building to have greater visual clarity in its landscape setting with Calton Hill.  We particular welcome the new landscape structure which provides new pleasure grounds and event spaces around the main building.  This will have a both a positive impact on the setting of this A-listed building as well as enhancing the character of this part of the Conservation Area.

The reduction in scope of the proposals from both the failed hotel schemes and the abandoned Music School scheme results in much “lighter touch” internal changes.  We are particularly supportive of the use of existing lower spaces rather than previous ideas which involved significant (and expensive) alterations.   Additionally, we accept the interventions to facilitate barrier free access – such as the new openings proposed for the east and west pavilions.

Finally, the opening up and access to the previously hidden belvedere/clock tower at the south-east corner is a welcome outcome.

For the sake of clarity, we note the changes in level proposed at the Western pavilion end, but feel that these are proportionate in order to facilitate the wider and more flexible use of proposed new facilities.  Bringing otherwise hidden areas of landscape around the building into active use is also supportable.

In summary, we welcome these proposals, believing that they result in a suitable reuse but in a manner which reinforces the essential heritage value of the site, rather than detracting from it.